Careful What You Fish For…

This story has already seen quite a bit of action in the Blogosphere but it was so good I couldn’t resist posting it here as well.

In recent years fMRI stories have become common and the technique has proved valuable for determining the internal state of a person’s brain while they complete specified tasks that allow researchers to draw conclusions about how our brains work. However the technology must be employed carefully otherwise spurious results will mar the integrity of the research. This point was amusingly demonstrated by Neuroscientist Craig Bennett when he decided to process the fMRI data collected from a dead Atlantic Salmon. Yep they scanned a fish.

Here’s a quote from the poster presented at the Human Brain Mapping conference.:

Subject. One mature Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar) participated in the fMRI study.
The salmon was approximately 18 inches long, weighed 3.8 lbs, and was not alive at
the time of scanning.

Task. The task administered to the salmon involved completing an open-ended
mentalizing task. The salmon was shown a series of photographs depicting human
individuals in social situations with a specified emotional valence. The salmon was
asked to determine what emotion the individual in the photo must have been
experiencing.

After reviewing the data Bennett was surprised to discover a significant signal in the fish’s brain. Discussions on the metaphysics of post mortem mental lives of piscines aside, this was obviously a false positive. After much debate Bennett decided that this was a good example of why careful filtering of the data procuded by these machines is a must in order to draw valid conclusions. Read Bennett’s description of event’s at his Blog and see the poster based on the data Here.

  1. Are you someone’s Dad, that title is very much a Dad-level pun…

    In a similar vein to this post you might want to read Leonard Leibovici (2001) who found that praying for a group of patients in the year 2000 significantly increased their health in 1996…

  2. I’m old before my time, thanks for noticing.

    That study was hilarious, thanks for sharing, I know what I’ll be boring my friends about for the next week.

  3. Hi!

    Congratulations! Your readers have submitted and voted for your blog at The Daily Reviewer. We compiled an exclusive list of the Top 100 rationality Blogs, and we are glad to let you know that your blog was included! You can see it at http://thedailyreviewer.com/top/rationality

    You can claim your Top 100 Blogs Award here : http://thedailyreviewer.com/pages/badges/rationality

    P.S. This is a one-time notice to let you know your blog was included in one of our Top 100 Blog categories. You might get notices if you are listed in two or more categories.

    P.P.S. If for some reason you want your blog removed from our list, just send an email to angelina@thedailyreviewer.com with the subject line “REMOVE” and the link to your blog in the body of the message.

    Cheers!

    Angelina Mizaki
    Selection Committee President
    The Daily Reviewer

    http://thedailyreviewer.com

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 69 other followers

%d bloggers like this: